Division II
| Player | High School | State | Year(s)* | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Drew Babcock | Gentry | AR | 2006 | University of Arkansas Ft Smith |
| Patrick Bennett | Seneca | MO | 2006-07 | Missouri Southern State University |
| Josh Brock | Willard | MO | 2006 | Southwest Baptist University |
| Jeremy Burba | Batesville | AR | 2004 | Southern Arkansas University |
| Zach Caldwell | St Mary Colgan | KS | 2006 | Missouri Southern State University |
| Patrick Chandler | Nixa | MO | 2008-09 | Rockhurst University |
| Shayne Hoke | Joplin | MO | 2007 | Missouri Southern State University |
| Tyler Jinks | Glendale | MO | 2005-06 | Missouri Southern State University |
| Luke Lawver | Joplin | MO | 2002 | Missouri Southern State University |
| Zack Manns | Pittsburg | KS | 2002 | Pittsburg State University |
| C.J. Matthews | Green Forest | AR | 2004 | Missouri Southern State University |
| Garrett Meyer | Fayetteville | AR | 2005-07 | University of Arkansas Ft Smith |
| Gordon Miller | Har-Ber | AR | 2009 | University of Arkansas Ft Smith |
| Jared Richmond | Van Buren | AR | 2006 | Tusculum College |
| Brent Robison | Tulsa Union | OK | 2004-05 | Central Missouri State University |
| Courtney Spitz | Kickapoo | MO | 2006 | Drury University |
| Matt Teale | Lakeside | AR | 2002-03 | Delta State University |
| Harrison Waters | Republic | MO | 2006 | Drury University |
| Laurent Zenoni | Bishop Kelley | OK | 2007-08 | Drury University |
(*) – asterisk indicates year(s) that player was with the Midwest Nationals.
